UNSTRUCTURED ALPHAMeasure a portfolio

VTV vs VYM

On none of the 19 forces measured do VTV and VYM differ by more than the noise in the readings: their 90% ranges overlap every time.

VTVVYMBars: 90% ranges. Hollow: could not be told apart from zero.Same figures in the table below.
Economic forceVTVVanguard Value ETFVYMVanguard High Dividend Yield ETF
Interest ratesIn weeks when the 10-year Treasury yield rose 0.25 percentage points−0.80%−1.2% to −0.40%Clear−0.76%−1.2% to −0.34%Clear
Inflation expectationsIn weeks when 10-year inflation expectations rose 0.25 percentage points+1.6%+0.69% to +2.5%Clear+1.9%+0.90% to +2.9%Clear
U.S. dollarIn weeks when the trade-weighted U.S. dollar rose 2%−0.39%−0.78% to +0.01%Not distinguishable from zero−0.46%−0.87% to −0.05%Tentative
Oil and energyIn weeks when the price of oil rose 10%−0.08%−0.38% to +0.23%Not distinguishable from zero+0.02%−0.25% to +0.29%Not distinguishable from zero
Credit spreadsIn weeks when corporate credit spreads widened 0.25 percentage points−0.40%−1.1% to +0.34%Not distinguishable from zero−0.37%−1.1% to +0.31%Not distinguishable from zero
Short-term ratesIn weeks when the 2-year Treasury yield rose 0.25 percentage points+0.03%−0.63% to +0.70%Not distinguishable from zero−0.11%−0.77% to +0.55%Not distinguishable from zero
Market volatilityIn weeks when market volatility (the VIX) rose 5 points−0.60%−0.88% to −0.32%Clear−0.47%−0.74% to −0.20%Tentative
Mortgage ratesIn weeks when the 30-year mortgage rate rose 0.25 percentage points+0.20%−0.15% to +0.54%Not distinguishable from zero+0.16%−0.20% to +0.51%Not distinguishable from zero
GoldIn weeks when the price of gold rose 5%+0.02%−0.26% to +0.30%Not distinguishable from zero+0.04%−0.21% to +0.29%Not distinguishable from zero
CopperIn weeks when the price of copper rose 5%+0.15%−0.05% to +0.35%Not distinguishable from zero+0.10%−0.11% to +0.30%Not distinguishable from zero
Natural gasIn weeks when the U.S. natural gas price (Henry Hub) rose 10%−0.01%−0.02% to 0.00%Not distinguishable from zero−0.01%−0.03% to 0.00%Tentative
BitcoinIn weeks when the price of bitcoin rose 10%−0.23%−0.52% to +0.07%Not distinguishable from zero−0.21%−0.52% to +0.11%Not distinguishable from zero
Small vs large companiesIn weeks when small companies beat large ones by 1 percentage point+0.34%+0.27% to +0.42%Clear+0.33%+0.27% to +0.40%Clear
Value vs growthIn weeks when value stocks beat growth stocks by 1 percentage point+0.54%+0.50% to +0.58%Clear+0.52%+0.47% to +0.57%Clear
MomentumIn weeks when recent winners beat the stock market by 1 percentage point−0.07%−0.20% to +0.06%Not distinguishable from zero−0.13%−0.25% to −0.02%Tentative
EuroIn weeks when the euro rose 2% against the U.S. dollar−0.62%−1.3% to +0.08%Not distinguishable from zero−0.50%−1.2% to +0.17%Not distinguishable from zero
Japanese yenIn weeks when the yen rose 2% against the U.S. dollar−0.11%−0.40% to +0.17%Not distinguishable from zero−0.04%−0.32% to +0.23%Not distinguishable from zero
Emerging marketsIn weeks when emerging-market stocks beat the S&P 500 by 1 percentage point−0.01%−0.10% to +0.09%Not distinguishable from zero−0.03%−0.12% to +0.07%Not distinguishable from zero
ChinaIn weeks when Chinese stocks beat other emerging markets by 1 percentage point+0.04%−0.01% to +0.08%Not distinguishable from zero+0.05%+0.01% to +0.09%Tentative
Each figure is the stock's typical move in a week when the force moved by the stated amount, after accounting for the stock market, with its 90% range beneath. Grey figures could not be told apart from zero. A row is marked a clear difference only when the two 90% ranges do not overlap.

This describes the past, and it is not a forecast. Relationships change, and nothing here is a recommendation to buy, sell or hold any security.

Measure VTV and VYM togetherWhat if? Move a force

Your portfolio, measured the same way

Every figure on these pages is one stock at a time. The app measures a whole portfolio: which forces it is exposed to, which holdings cause it, and how sure the reading is. Free, no account for the first report.